Buying guide: set the criteria buyers judge your category on

One page that tells buyers what to judge on, what to look for and what to avoid, written by you.

Flemming RubakFlemming Rubak · November 18, 2026 · 5 min read

Buyers who don’t know a category ask AI what to judge on. In US CRM platforms they ask “What are the core features we should be looking for in a CRM platform?”1 The answer becomes the checklist every provider is measured against.

In most markets nobody owns that checklist. In UK strategy consulting, ten criteria decide the answers and not one has a firm the models reach for.2 Across 1,094 US categories in ChatGPT, only 15.2% have a clear owner.3

A Buying guide gives the model the checklist, in your words. Here is what one looks like.


Example: Brightwater Facility Services (a fictional commercial cleaning company)

Title

How to choose a commercial cleaning company: the 5 criteria that matter

Why it’s here

“How to” titles are among the most cited in Google AI Mode and Perplexity.4 The number tells the model the list is complete.

Opening line

Judge a cleaning company on five things: who checks the work, how staff are vetted, cover when a cleaner is ill, the price per square metre, and the contract terms. The first decides most outcomes.

Why it’s here

The whole checklist in two sentences, with a position on what matters most. AI can quote it as the answer.

Updated date

Updated 1 November 2026

Why it’s here

Criteria and prices move. Three in four pages AI cites were updated within the last year.5

Why the usual criteria fall short

“Price per hour hides the hours. Compare the price per square metre and what it includes.”

Why it’s here

It moves the buyer from the criterion everyone uses to the one that predicts the result.

The criteria

Each criterion, what to look for and the red flag
CriterionWhat to look forRed flag
Who checks the workA named supervisor and a written check every week“The cleaners check themselves”
How staff are vettedBackground checks and training records you can seeNo answer in writing
Cover when a cleaner is illA named stand-in within 24 hours“We’ll do our best”
Price per square metreOne price, with what is includedAn hourly rate with no hours stated
Contract termsThree months’ notice or lessA 12-month lock-in

Why it’s here

One row per criterion lets the model lift any of them on its own.

Where we stand

Brightwater has a named supervisor for every site, checks every cleaner’s background, and covers illness within 24 hours. At €2.40 per square metre a month it is not the cheapest; the price includes weekly checks and all materials.

Why it’s here

Your own answer, weaker points included, is what makes the guide a source and not an advert.

The checklist

  1. Who checks the work, by name?
  2. Can I see your vetting and training records?
  3. Who covers when a cleaner is ill, and how fast?
  4. What is the price per square metre, and what does it include?
  5. What is the notice period?

Why it’s here

The model can reuse a checklist when buyers ask how to choose, with your page as the source.

Next step

Get a price per square metre from Brightwater

Why it’s here

It moves the buyer from choosing to asking you.


Build yours

  • Collect: the criteria buyers should judge on, what to look for under each, and your honest answer on each. Sales and product hold them.
  • Outline: why the usual criteria fall short, one section per criterion (what to look for, the red flag), how to score, a checklist.
  • Two versions:
    • Checklist: how to choose, criterion by criterion. The example above.
    • Criteria shift: the case for a criterion the market underrates, backed by evidence.

    Once buyers know the criteria, they compare: give them a Comparison page.

  • The page mechanics: how to mark up the page, structure the headings and show the update date are in the techniques: schema, headings and update dates.

Put it where AI looks

  • Your industry association or trade media: offer the checklist as a resource they can publish or link.
  • A LinkedIn article by the person who wrote it, linking the guide.
  • Check after eight weeks: ask “how do I choose a [category]?” again and see whether your criteria now shape the answer.

How Seedli does this for you

Seedli finds the criteria the models judge your market on, and the ones nobody owns. It recommends the content type that fits each gap and writes a brief to match: the facts to collect and who holds them, the outline, and what helps AI find the page: the title, the meta description, the page address, answers to the follow-up searches AI runs behind the question, and the links and link text to use from your other pages. Eight weeks after placing, Seedli checks whether the answers changed.


Good to know

  • Give your honest answer on every criterion, including where you are weaker.
  • Update the guide once a year, and when prices in the category change.

Sources

  1. The Sunday Shortlist, US CRM platforms, Recommendation Design, August 2026.
  2. The Sunday Shortlist, UK strategy consulting, Recommendation Design, November 2026.
  3. Semrush, ChatGPT topic authority study, 2026.
  4. HubSpot, Content formats that earn AI citations, 2026.
  5. Seer Interactive, How content recency impacts AI citations, 2026.
Buying guide: set the criteria buyers judge your category on | Seedli